The Chaos Of Clean-Up
Analysis of Potential Health and Environmental Impacts of Chemicals in Dispersant Products. The report, The Chaos Of Clean-Up, was prepared by Toxipedia Consulting Services and Earthjustice.
The report was funded by the Gulf Restoration Network and Florida Wildlife Federation.
The Chaos of CleanupThe Chaos Of Clean-Up
Following the Deepwater Horizon oil spill, chemical oil dispersants were applied in unprecedented amounts both at the ocean’s surface and underwater at the well head.
The report, The Chaos Of Clean-Up, was prepared in response to widespread public concern among Gulf Coast communities about the safety of chemicals, known as dispersants, that were poured into the Gulf of Mexico to disperse oil during the Deepwater Horizon disaster. This report presents findings from a literature review of scientific research on each of 57 chemical ingredients that are found in dispersants that were eligible for use at the time of the Deepwater Horizon disaster. The ingredients and formulas for various dispersants on the market typically are not available, and it is not fully known which chemical ingredients among the 57 are found in which dispersant.
The review demonstrates the wide range of potential impacts from exposure to the chemicals found in dispersants. From carcinogens, to endocrine disruptors, to chemicals that are toxic to aquatic organisms, some of the ingredients in oil dispersants are indeed potential hazards. For instance, of the 57 ingredients,
5 chemicals are associated with cancer
33 chemicals are associated with skin irritation, from rashes to burns
33 chemicals are linked to eye irritation
11 chemicals are suspected or potential respiratory toxins or irritants
10 chemicals are suspected kidney toxins.
As for potential effects on the marine environment,
8 chemicals are suspected or known to be toxic to aquatic organisms
5 chemicals are suspected to have a moderate acute toxicity to fish
Clearly, some of the chemical ingredients are more toxic than others, and some dispersants are more toxic in particular environments. The widely-varying toxicity of different dispersants underscores the importance of full disclosure and proper selection of dispersants for use in oil spill response.
While revealing some of the potential hazards of dispersants, the literature review also highlights the extent of our current lack of knowledge about dispersants and their impacts. Ultimately, the absence of thorough scientific research on dispersants and the chemicals that comprise dispersants, as well as the lack of public disclosure of each dispersant’s ingredients and formulation, hinders any effort to understand the full impacts of dispersant use. These findings call for more research, greater disclosure of the information that is known, comprehensive toxicity testing, the establishment of safety criteria for dispersants, and careful selection of the least toxic dispersants for application in oil spill response.